How to Make Your Own Mayonnaise

Homemade mayonnaise is healthy, simple, and easy.

As an Amazon Associate, Breathe Together Yoga earns from qualifying purchases.

Mayonnaise sauce and ingredients on white stone table. Top view with copy space.

Up until recently, I never liked mayo because of the ingredients. The sheer thought of store-bought mayo and what might be in it grossed me out, until I learned that it is surprisingly simple to make your own.

Quality is always key when it comes to ingredients. With making raw mayo, it is even more important – especially when it comes to eggs, since we’ll be using raw eggs. Worried about salmonella? Don’t be! Pasture-raised eggs from healthy chickens – those that are able to scratch and peck while being exposed to sunlight – are not a threat for carrying salmonella. On that note, I avoid buying eggs with a label that says “fed a 100 percent vegetarian diet” because it is a guarantee that the chickens were never outside in nature. Healthy chickens should be outside and consuming their natural food diet, including worms and insects. This ensures that they can lay eggs with an optimal omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, and eggs will be high in essential nutrients, including B vitamins, choline, and selenium. Those kinds of eggs are hardly found in any store-bought mayonnaise.

Next, let’s look at the oils. Most store-bought mayo is made with canola oil and/or other processed vegetable oils high in polyunsaturated fatty acids. These polyunsaturated fatty acids are heat sensitive and often reflect an unhealthy omega-6 to omega-3 ratio (meaning too much omega-6). Most vegetable oils, which are actually seed oils, are also highly processed using heat and chemical solvents. Better oils for making mayo are monounsaturated oils, such olive oil, avocado oil, or high-oleic sunflower oil, which mimics the fatty acid profile of olive oil. To get your daily intake of polyunsaturated fatty acids, you might consider getting them in the form of nuts or fish high in omega-3. When I started making mayo, I was not keen on the bitter taste of olive oil, so I avoided it completely by using tasteless sunflower oil. Then, I experimented a bit more with combining the two, and now I actually prefer to use more olive oil than sunflower oil.

The other ingredients are freshly-squeezed lemon juice (an emulsifier), dijon mustard, and salt to provide additional flavor. I usually use pink Himalayan salt to get as many trace minerals as possible. There is one more ingredient I like to add: whey, which acts as a preservative here. Whey is the yellowish fluid from plain yogurt. You can get it by straining yogurt through a sifter lined with a cheesecloth. The remaining solid is cream cheese (ready to eat!), while the fluid is the whey, which can be used as a starter for lacto-fermentation (see note below), the traditional process of preserving food by letting the good bacteria multiply to keep the bad ones in check.

And that’s it! This lacto-fermented mayonnaise is something I’ve grown really fond of. Besides tasting yummy, it adds nutrients (including enzymes and probiotics) to the diet and, as promised, is really easy to make!

Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe

(adapted, with permission, from Nourishing Traditions)

Ingredients

1 whole egg, ideally pasture raised
1 egg yolk, ideally pasture raised
1 tsp dijon mustard
1 ½ tbsp lemon juice
1/4 + 1/8 tsp celtic sea salt or pink Himalayan salt
1 tbsp whey (optional for lacto-fermentation*)
1 cup combination of high oleic sunflower oil or avocado oil and olive oil

Directions

Place all ingredients except the oil in a jar, and blend for a few seconds with a hand blender. Add the oil, and use the blender to let the mayo emulsify. 

Notes

  • *If whey is used, then let the mayo sit for seven hours or overnight at room temperature to allow the lactobacillus to work and multiply before putting it in the fridge. It will keep for several months. The texture will get firmer over time.
  • Without the whey, the mayo will keep for about 10 days in the refrigerator.
  • If you prefer a milder-tasting mayonnaise, then use only a little olive oil. My favorite combination is a bit more olive oil than sunflower oil, resulting in a stronger-tasting mayo.
Picture of Judith Steger

Judith Steger

Judith (pronounced "you did") started to study nutrition on a deeper level in 2007, after her daughter was born, when all the recommended rice cereal reminded her more of shredded cardboard than nutritious, baby food. Judith is a passionate cook, preparing most of her food from scratch, and a dedicated student of homeopathy, which helped her heal her gluten sensitivity. She is also a yoga teacher, offering classes that feel nourishing for the mind, body, and soul – whether they are gentle or led in a more vigorous way.

One reply on “How to Make Your Own Mayonnaise”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shine Your Way to Firefly | Izumi Sato

We aim to improve the flexibility of hamstrings and shoulders, as well as the strength in the arms, thigh adductors, and the core. Variations are offered to develop the sense of balance on the arms. It is an exploration of your own expression in Firefly, whatever stage of life you’re in.

Introduction to the Buddhist Mudras | Izumi Sato

Mudras are highly stylized and symbolized as non-verbal communication. In this introduction to the Buddhist mudras, we will learn five Buddhist mudras and the mudras of the five wisdoms, or five Buddhas. After learning the forms and meanings of the mudras, it’s fun to observe the arts such as Buddha sculptures and paintings.

Chanting Gayatri Mantra With Mudras | Izumi Sato

In this mantra, the 24 Mudras are practiced while chanting the Gayatri Mantra which has 24 syllables. Gayatri Mantra is dedicated to Savitri, a Vedic sun deity. Among various translations of the mantra, I introduce the first line by Tias Little and the rest of the lines by Swami Vivekananda.

How Mindfulness Can Help You Navigate Social Media

Now that social media has become an extension of our own communities, a lot of negative perspectives and habits have made their way from the digital world to our real one. By becoming aware of your emotions and actions, you can get past the bad side of social media and enjoy the company of your social circle.

Intro to Mysore Style Vinyasa

This introductory course is designed to provide the participants a step-by-step guide to learn Mysore Style Ashtanga Vinyasa Yoga.