4 Stages of Moral Suffering to Navigate Trauma

Understanding empathy’s double edge, according to a Buddhist teacher.

As an Amazon Associate, Breathe Together Yoga earns from qualifying purchases.

ripple in water

I don’t like to ingest much of the news these days. I feel like there is a sucking energy, much like a high-powered vacuum, that pulls me into concern, agitation, or downright frustration. Every now and again, however, something occurs that forces me to open my eyes and heart and look deeper. 

We have friends who were recently involved in a tragic car crash. The crash took the lives of a mother and her two young children. Our friends were behind the car whose lives were lost. Within moments, the two cars rolled and filled with flames. Miraculously, our friends survived the crash. They remember being pulled from the car from first responders, heroes who risked their lives to help others. This reminds me of our first responders during the COVID-19 pandemic: health professionals and essential workers who continue serving the needs of our community above their own. We have modern-day superheroes, and, lucky for us, they keep showing up. Tears well in my eyes when I feel the gravity of these moments. For all those involved with this tragic situation, intense emotions still arise: Fear. Relief. Frustration. Anger. Curiosity. Primordial emotions.  

In the depths of my own emotional vulnerability, I came across a podcast from Buddhist Teacher Roshi Joan Halifax called “Empathy’s Double-Edge.” I found her description of moral suffering fascinating. Maybe you will too. These thoughts may be helpful to anyone dealing with tough emotions, whether surviving trauma or frustrated by the circumstances around them: 

Four Stages of Moral Suffering

  1. Moral distress. When we are confronted by egregious harm but feel we can’t do anything.
  2. Moral injury. When we are traumatized and the memory lives within us.
  3. Moral outrage. When anger and disgust hit, or we perceive an action as a violation. Often, this phase is when we move into blame and shame. What is interesting is when an episodic event spurs moral outage, social change can happen. It’s only when chronic moral outrage hits that we find ourselves stuck and bitter.
  4. Moral apathy. When we choose to stay in a bubble of separateness, contributing to the suffering of others, knowingly or unknowingly

Whether caught up in personal or collective trauma, we may receive clarity in these stages. With COVID-19, in some cases, people have experienced great loss. In others, life may seem greatly improved with the forced slow-down. Whatever the case, this circumstance brings us to greater awareness of our interconnection. We have all traversed the bumpy road of grief and transition from one state of being to another. What we hope transpires – to learn from this time and allow it to change us for the better – is social change. We don’t need to come out of this situation with a desire for things to return to “the way they were.” Instead, might we treasure the connectedness we’ve built.  

May we continue to be generous to our neighbors.  
May we continue to slow down.
May we appreciate the value of spending time cooking and cleaning in our homes.
May we support the local businesses we want to survive in our communities.
May we take walks and appreciate the fresh air Mother Nature provides us each and every day.
May we carve out time for family connection.
May we treasure game night with puzzles and old-fashioned board games.
May we laugh.
May we play.
May we trust.
May we love.
May we appreciate the beauty and connection we treasure most.

Picture of Christina Roberts Enneking

Christina Roberts Enneking

Christina has been practicing yoga for over three decades, drawn to the practice as a release from stress and a way to more deeply integrate the body, mind, and spirit. A certified 500-hour master yoga instructor and reiki practitioner, Christina has studied and practiced with many master teachers across the globe and her style is a fun-loving blend of Vinyasa Flow, Qigong, and energy work. Her specialty is meeting people where they are and offering practices that facilitate deeper growth, sweeter stability, and genuine joy. In addition to leading service-based yoga retreats, helping to deliver solar light to people living off the power grid, Christina facilitates learning workshops at multiple companies in Silicon Valley, focusing on brain-based leadership techniques for maximizing personal effectiveness and gaining mastery, autonomy, and purpose in life.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shine Your Way to Firefly | Izumi Sato

We aim to improve the flexibility of hamstrings and shoulders, as well as the strength in the arms, thigh adductors, and the core. Variations are offered to develop the sense of balance on the arms. It is an exploration of your own expression in Firefly, whatever stage of life you’re in.

Introduction to the Buddhist Mudras | Izumi Sato

Mudras are highly stylized and symbolized as non-verbal communication. In this introduction to the Buddhist mudras, we will learn five Buddhist mudras and the mudras of the five wisdoms, or five Buddhas. After learning the forms and meanings of the mudras, it’s fun to observe the arts such as Buddha sculptures and paintings.

Chanting Gayatri Mantra With Mudras | Izumi Sato

In this mantra, the 24 Mudras are practiced while chanting the Gayatri Mantra which has 24 syllables. Gayatri Mantra is dedicated to Savitri, a Vedic sun deity. Among various translations of the mantra, I introduce the first line by Tias Little and the rest of the lines by Swami Vivekananda.

How Mindfulness Can Help You Navigate Social Media

Now that social media has become an extension of our own communities, a lot of negative perspectives and habits have made their way from the digital world to our real one. By becoming aware of your emotions and actions, you can get past the bad side of social media and enjoy the company of your social circle.

Moon Salutations | Pim Kunakasem

This variation of Moon Salutations includes some mobility, which aids in the recovery of runners, cyclists, or those after a long day seated in a chair.

No Loss for Words: Language Development for Yoga Teachers

Have you ever participated in a yoga class that completely transformed some element of your practice? Perhaps you were so deeply moved by something in the class that you left feeling forever changed, or a pose that once eluded you suddenly became possible.